Welcome to Cherry's On The Bay

158 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 11782, United States

General Info

Cherry's On The Bay sits right along the waterfront at Cherry Grove, and from the moment you arrive at 158 Bayview Walk, the vibe feels relaxed, social, and unmistakably fun. This is not just a place to eat-it’s a dance restaurant where food, drinks, music, and movement blend naturally into one lively experience. The location alone adds to the charm, making it easy to settle in and enjoy the energy of the bay.

The menu keeps things approachable while still feeling special. Drinks are a major part of the experience here, and the Bloody Mary is a standout, bold and balanced, perfect for easing into the day during breakfast hours. For those leaning toward something sweeter or more playful, the Cherry Bomb lives up to its name, while the Apple Martini and the Mary Tini bring a smooth, refreshing finish that pairs well with the upbeat atmosphere, especially during happy-hour drinks.

Food-wise, the Seafood Platter anchors the menu and feels right at home by the water. It’s generous, satisfying, and designed for sharing, which fits the social nature of the space. Whether you’re stopping in early for breakfast or drifting in later as the music picks up, the menu flows easily with the pace of the day and night. Reviews often highlight how effortless it feels to stay longer than planned once food and drinks hit the table.

Live music plays a central role here, setting the tone as the restaurant shifts into dance mode. The sound fills the space without overpowering conversation, and before long, the dining room transforms into a dance floor where movement feels spontaneous rather than staged. It’s that seamless transition that defines Cherry's On The Bay as more than a typical restaurant.

Practical details are handled just as thoughtfully. Guests will find a wheelchair-accessible toilet, debit cards are accepted for convenience, and service stays friendly even when the place is buzzing. Among local locations in Cherry Grove, this spot stands out for how naturally it balances dining, drinks, and dancing into one continuous, feel-good experience that keeps people coming back and talking about it long after they leave.

Cherry's On The Bay Photos 2

Cherry's On The Bay Photos

Icon

What customers say?

“ Cherry's on the Bay go during a Drag show or a weekend night, and you'll have a blast. I can promise dollar for dollar its amazing ! It's a required life experience if your coming to F.I. and the best part is you can feel the vibe outside before you go spend your $$$s inside ”

- Numbahz -

“ Fun spot on the water. I didn’t eat here-just drinks and dancing. The dj was good and the drinks were good-except out last order they messed up and gave us vodka tonics instead of vodka seltzers. It’s so busy we couldn’t correct. They also don’t let you bring in your beach bag so be prepared. I will go back for more fun! ”

- Dani D -

“ My favorite place to get cocktails on Fire Island and the food is always good. ”

- Miguel Ruiz -

“ Didn’t eat here but my girlfriend and I went for drinks and drag brunch. Genuinely one of the most fun times I’ve ever had. The drinks were good, bartenders were attentive, and the drag queens put on an amazing show. They are so talented. Came back later for another show and it was less crowded but just as good!! Can’t wait to come back someday soon. ”

- Ava M -
Banner

Location & Contact

call to book a table & delivery:
information Cherry's On The Bay:

158 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove, NY 11782, United States

See more food places

Cafe
31 Duthy St, Unley SA 5061, Australia
Thai restaurant
804 McMinnville Hwy, Woodbury, TN 37190, United States
Restaurant
71 Potomac Ave SE, Washington, DC 20003, United States
Taco restaurant
5895 Katella Ave Ste. B, Cypress, CA 90630, United States
Sri Lankan restaurant
230 Union Rd, Ascot Vale VIC 3032, Australia